Renal papillary necrosis. Irregularly round or oval areas of yellow necrosis are seen in renal papilla and medullary areas of the kidney from a 62-year-old female with type 1 diabetes mellitus. A urinary tract infection was also present as evidenced by the mildly inflamed renal pelvis epithelium (acute pyelitis). Picture provided by Dr. Stephen A. Geller - personal archive.:In 1877, Dr. Nikolaus Friedreich1 (1825-1882; student of Virchow who became Professor of Pathology at Heidelberg and who also described Friedreich’s ataxia) first described renal papillary necrosis (RPN) in patients with prostatic hypertrophy and secondary hydronephrosis. Thereafter in 1937, Froboese2 and Günther3 emphasized the association of this entity with diabetes mellitus. These authors also observed renal papillary necrosis in cases of urinary tract obstruction even in the absence of diabetes mellitus.
In 1952, Mandel’s4 report corroborated the latter findings, suggesting that urinary tract infection played a role in the pathogenesis of RPN. His report showed the presence of urinary infection in 95% of cases of RPN, in autopsy studies. It was in the late 1950s that analgesics emerged as a major etiological factor of RPN.5 Since then some series reported that analgesic abuse accounted for 80 – 90% of cases of RPN.5-7 In this setting non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID) are also included with their incidence increasing as these medications are more often utilized. The risk highest is for phenacetin (no longer used in many countries) and acetaminophen. In general, the risk for analgesic nephropathy is cumulative. More recently, it has been shown that these drugs are harmful to human kidneys in the presence of volume depletion, underlying renal disease as well as long-term abuse.8 Other causes of RPN include: sickle-cell hemoglobinopathies9,10, post-renal transplants11, chronic liver disease12, shock and severe dehydration, the latter mainly observed during infancy.5
The principal causes are summarized in Table 1.
Major causes of renal papillary necrosis (RPN):
Sickle cell nephropathy
Diabetes mellitus, often with urinary tract infection
Prolonged use of NSAIDs
An expanded list of causes is summarized with the English language mnemonic “POSTCARDS” (pyelonephritis, obstructive uropathy, sickle cell disease, tuberculosis, chronic liver disease, analgesic/alcohol, renal transplant rejection, diabetes mellitus, systemic vasculitis).13
The frequency of RPN in different disease conditions is unknown because of underdiagnosed pauci- or asymptomatic cases. However approximately 30% of all cases of RPN occur in the setting of diabetes mellitus. In these cases, hyperglycemia is usually uncontrolled, and urinary tract infections are frequently seen. The relationship of RPN with diabetic microangiopathy could be demonstrated either in vivo or in an autopsy series.14
Friedreich5 proposed a vascular mechanism to explain the RPN regardless of underlying disease. Unequivocally, this mechanism is observed in sickle cell disease, where vasa recta are obstructed by the sickling erythrocytes. In case of analgesics and NSAID, ischemia can be demonstrated in the medulla and vasa recta due to direct inhibition of cyclooxygenase-mediated production of prostaglandins.8 A direct toxic effect on cells of the medulla is also involved in the pathogenesis of RPN. Damage to these cells may similarly reflect as effects on vasculature, since medullary interstitial cells synthesize prostaglandins. Studies have also shown that ischemia results from direct endothelial cell damage.15 Regardless the involved mechanism, the end result is reduced prostaglandin production, leading to decreased vascular perfusion, vasoconstriction and eventually ischemic necrosis.8
The lack of specific symptoms, in the early stages, makes diagnosis challenging. Later clinical features include: nocturia, dysuria, pyuria, hematuria (most notably microscopic hematuria), ureteral colic, necrotic papillae voided in the urine6 and back pain. Renal function studies may also reveal decreased glomerular filtration rate (GFR), increased urea blood nitrogen (BUN) and renal tubular acidosis. Eventually RPN leads to death or chronic renal failure.8
Histologically, renal papillary necrosis is characterized by coagulative necrosis of the renal papilla and the background medullary pyramids. Subsequently the necrotic foci can become infected either from ascending cystitis or hematogenous dissemination and be seen as acute liquefactive necrosis with potential abscess formation. The papilla, whether infected or not, can cause renal tubular obstruction. Sloughed papilla can be seen in cytopathology preparations of urine. In time fibrosis and calcification occur. Bilateral involvement, or involvement of a solitary kidney, can lead to renal failure. If renal papillary necrosis is complicated by infection can lead to death, particularly in the diabetic patient who may or may not have other significant medical problems. Even in the non-diabetic patient, renal papillary necrosis is potentially fatal.
As a last note, it has been suggested that the first description of RPN is in the record of Beethoven’s autopsy.16 The translation of the original Latin of the report says, “every one of their calices was occupied by a calcareous concretion of a wart-like shape and is large as a split pea.” In a subsequent paper17, the wording of the translation was changed to “every single calyx was filled with a calcareous concretion like a pea which had been cut across the middle.” In addition, the renal capsule is described as a “cellular membrane of an inch thick,” indicative of chronic renal inflammation rather than acutely occurring RPN. This may, instead of RPN, be a description of extensive nephrolithiasis in association with chronic pyelonephritis. When RPN develops it is typically irregular and does not affect “every single” papilla. Further the necrotic papilla slough and break off, to be excreted, and evidence would similarly not be present throughout. “Wart-like,” the descriptive term used, is not likely to be RPN, and, although color descriptors appear in other parts of the report, there is no use of “yellow,” typical of necrosis, in the kidney section. The pathologist, Johann Wagner, was experienced and highly regarded, including by his student Karl von Rokitansky, developer of the great Viennese school of pathology. As was the custom of the time the report concentrates on explaining clinical problems and the prostate gland, likely enlarged in a 57 year old man and possibly the cause of at least partial obstruction and subsequent pyelonephritis, is not mentioned. In addition it is highly unlikely that he would have mistaken the papilla for a calyx, since the anatomy of the kidney had been well described by Marcello Malpighi (1628-1694) two centuries before.
EdmondsonRPS, FawcetTW, JonesNF, CadeR, TarrantDG, JuncosLI. Papillary necrosis in a transplanted kidney. BMJ. 1972;1:547. http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmj.1.5799.547.
EdmondsonHA, ReynoldsTB, JacobsonHG. Renal papillary necrosis with special reference to chronic alcoholism. Arch Intern Med. 1966;118:255. http://dx.doi.org/10.1001/archinte.1966.00290150069013.
Powell C, Donohoe JM, Mydlo JH. Papillary necrosis [Internet]. Medscape; 2012. [cited 2013 Oct 2]. Available from: http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/439586-overview#a0102
GroopL, LaasonenL, EdgrenJ. Renal papillary necrosis in patients with IDDM. Diabetes Care. 1989;12:198-202. http://dx.doi.org/10.2337/diacare.12.3.198.
WolfDC, TurekJJ, CarltonWW. Early sequential ultrastructural renal altrations induced by 2-bromoethylamine hydrobromide in the Swiss ICR mouse. Vet Pathol. 1992;29:528-35. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/030098589202900607.
SchwarzA. Beethoven’s renal disease based on his autopsy: a case of papillary necrosis. Am J Kidney Dis. 1993;21:643-52.
DaviesPJ. Beethoven’s nephropathy and death: discussion paper. J R Soc Med. 1999;86:159-61.